The Legal Wake-Up Call SMEs Can’t Ignore
In January 2025, the UK Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling clarifying that “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 refers to biological sex, not gender identity. This ruling—For Women Scotland Ltd v Scottish Ministers—has sparked debate, confusion, and fear of missteps across workplaces.
For UK SMEs, especially in service-based, tech, and professional sectors, this isn’t just a headline. It’s a legal and cultural moment that demands thoughtful, proactive leadership. And not just around gender.
As we explore how to update your inclusivity strategy, the bigger question is this:
Are you building a workplace that balances legal compliance with genuine compassion?
Compliance + Compassion: The Dual Mandate for Inclusivity
The ruling doesn’t erase rights. Transgender and non-binary employees remain protected under the “gender reassignment” characteristic of the Equality Act. But it does mean your policies must be clear, lawful, and unambiguous.
Action:
- Update all diversity and equality policies to reflect that “sex” = biological sex.
- Add language affirming day-to-day respect for names, pronouns, and gender expression.
- Ensure your policy upholds rights and relationships: legality with humanity.
Navigating Division with Leadership, Not Avoidance
You may have team members with gender-critical beliefs (now protected under law) and others who identify as trans or non-binary. This can lead to tension.
Business leaders must foster dignity for both sides. It’s not about picking a side—it’s about upholding respect.
Action:
- Implement a Dignity at Work clause within your handbook or inclusivity policy.
- Train staff: What’s protected belief? What’s harassment? Where’s the line?
- Address conflict early. Equip managers with the skills to have difficult conversations constructively.
Where Most SMEs Are Missing the Mark: Neurodiversity
While gender makes headlines, most inclusion policies still miss out on a major area of untapped talent: neurodivergent people (ADHD, autism, dyslexia, etc.).
This isn’t just a moral oversight—it’s a legal and commercial risk. Neurodivergent conditions often qualify as disabilities. Failure to provide reasonable adjustments can lead to unlimited fines at tribunal.
Action:
- Add neurodiversity explicitly to your inclusivity policy.
- Designate a simple process to request and review adjustments.
- Train managers to understand the basics: what might neurodivergent staff need? What is a reasonable adjustment?
Simplified Adjustments: What Small, Remote Businesses Can Realistically Do
Reasonable adjustments don’t need to be expensive or complex. Often they involve:
- Flexible work hours
- Written vs. verbal instructions
- Headphones for focus
- Software tools (spellcheck, screen readers)
- Regular one-to-one check-ins
Set up a 3-step adjustment protocol:
- Employee discloses challenge/need.
- Manager/owner explores simple changes collaboratively.
- Review effectiveness within 4–6 weeks.
Keep a record. Show you took action.
Why This Matters to Your Bottom Line
Inclusion isn’t just about compliance—it’s good business. Diverse teams:
- Retain staff longer
- Innovate more
- Solve problems better
Conversely, legal risk from poor policies can cost tens of thousands in fines plus reputational damage.
Action:
- Schedule an annual policy review (or sooner after legal updates).
- Use this moment to relaunch your internal inclusion commitment.
- Consider anonymous surveys to ask: “Do you feel included? What could we do better?”
The Inclusive SME Checklist (For Business Owners Ready to Act)
- Update inclusivity policy to reflect 2025 legal definitions.
- Include gender identity and gender-critical beliefs under protected characteristics.
- Add neurodiversity explicitly to your inclusion strategy.
- Create or update a Reasonable Adjustments Policy.
- Train line managers to handle adjustments & conflict.
- Foster a culture of open dialogue and respect.
- Communicate changes to staff proactively.
Final Word: Inclusion is a Practice, Not a Policy
The best SMEs don’t just stay out of court. They build workplaces where people thrive, think differently, and know they matter.
This ruling is a chance to reset. A moment to lead, not hide. And a catalyst to shape a people-first future—rooted in law, and led with humanity.
Need help embedding these?
